Save-and-Refresh With Java Web Projects

How do you configure your machine in order to have save-and-refresh for Java web projects? When you ask this question to developers, the answer starts with “oh, well…”, and continues with a description of something that sort-of works. And everyone has his own way.

First – why do you need this? Because doing copying and restarting the server is a productivity killer – wastes a lot of your time. Without the productivity boost of syncing your project with the container, even for simple fixes, you may need a full build-and-deploy cycle before you can test it. And that may take a lot of time, depending on the size of the project.

I’ll write down a few, to complement my StackOverflow answer:

  • IDE integration – IDEs have an option to add a local server and deploy projects to it. That requires additional plugins, configuring what workspace files go where in the servlet container, and doesn’t always work. And when there is Maven in the picture, it either doesn’t work, or requires yet another plugin (as described in this answer of mine)
  • You use some tools for synchronizing directory structures. In Eclipse there’s the FileSync plugin, which let’s you configure which workspace files go where in the servlet container. Other tools may exist for doing the same thing (e.g. unison) , or you may have written some script or plugin to do it.
  • Running the servlet container from maven (if using maven) – either the tomcat plugin or the jetty plugin let you do that. The downside is that in order to run in debug mode, you need to attach external debugger (rather than using the built-in IDE-server integration for that). And it requires the plugin configuration. Also, have in mind that if using jetty (the faster option) for development, there might be difference in behaviour if your production container is tomcat. Not much of a hassle, but still something to have in mind.
  • Manually copying the project files – this doesn’t sound that terrible in the beginning, but then it starts bothering you – after all, it’s a task asking to be automated.

So, now you have your class files and resources (css, javascript, images, configuration files) copied to the servlet container. However, in order for them to work, you need some HotSwap functionality. That is, to let the jvm reload the class definitions. There are four options for that:

  • Regular HotSwap – simply run the servlet container in debug mode. You get the bodies of your methods swapped whenever you change the class file. However, changing the method or class signatures requires restart. I’ve always used this option, and it hasn’t been that painful – after all method signature redefinition and refactoring don’t happen too often, and even when they do, it’s ok to restart the server, because you are not focused on getting some particular feature to work.
  • DCEVM – a VM enhancement that allows complete reloading of classes. I haven’t used it, but if it works properly, it should address the signature redefinition problem mentioned above.
  • SpringLoaded – a project by spring for hot-swapping
  • JRebel – a commercial alternative. I’ve never used it, I’ve heard it’s good, and I know there are a lot of extras, that let you use it with various frameworks, so that reconfiguring the spring context, for example, doesn’t need a restart. I don’t think these things happen that often, and so I’ve never recommended JRebel (being commercial), but it’s an important option that you should consider.
  • Restarting the server on every change. If the project is small, this takes very little time and might be an option. But I wouldn’t recommend it even for small projects, as at least HotSwap is very easy to configure (and you need debug mode anyway)

So many options – so typical for the Java world. And they work more or less fine. However, I decided to add one more option, that has almost zero-configuration – aardWARk.

It works by putting the aardwark.war file in your tomcat, renaming it, so that the name includes the path to your project directory, and it handles the syncrhonization. Note that this is an option added to the first list above. For hotswapping you’d still need one of the three options in the second list. There is a more detailed setup guide on the project page, but there are a few things to emphasize:

  • it works only with maven projects. In order to have zero-configuration, the convention-over-configuration of maven needs to be used
  • it is IDE-independent and servlet-container-independent.
  • it does what I think no other solution above can do (apart from JRebel, probably) – it will synchronize the maven dependent projects as well. Normally, you have a multi-module project, where some projects are packaged as jars, and other (web) projects depend on them. But you need to be able to change a class in, say, the “core” module, and to immediately see the changes in the webapp. This would mean repackaging and reloading the jar. AardWARk simply parses the pom, finds the dependent projects and copies their classes to the classpath, which overrides the existing definitions
  • multiple projects are supported, and also configuration via a properties file (if you don’t want or can’t name the war file to contain the path to the project)
  • syncing jars files does not happen on changing the pom – you need a restart. It is running the copy-dependencies goal on an embedded maven
  • it’s called aardWARk for a simple reason – it would be best if this war file is loaded before the ones of your project. Not necessarily, as it is needed only for syncing the jar files, but preferably. Servlet containers do not guarantee the loading order of webapps, but it is likely that they are picked alphabetically – hence aardwark (war instead of var, for obvious reasons).

I hope it is a useful tool, and I’ll be glad if people start using it and give their feedback.

16 thoughts on “Save-and-Refresh With Java Web Projects”

  1. It is a nice post. Infact i too most often think that how we settle to restart web server even for a small change in java code. This thing really annoys me at work when server restart takes 1 to 2 minutes.
    One option provided by Spring is: Spring Loaded but i have not been able to configure it in a web project in eclipse. Also not found much documentation in this regard.
    For JRebel, i have just signed up for JRebel Social, which provides free license to individuals. Now i am going to try that free license that whether it works or not. And if it works, to which extent it provides ease.

  2. Awesome site you have here but I was curious about if you knew of any message boards that cover the same topics talked about in this article?
    I’d really like to be a part of online community
    where I can get responses from other experienced people that share the
    same interest. If you have any recommendations,
    please let me know. Thank you!

  3. Once the perfect attention grabbing description has been achieved, you have to
    identify the perfect spot on your page to position that descriptive link to your high paying page.
    Mary Kay is one of the most well-known and reputable direct sales
    companies. For instance, for fall and winter, you can fill the air with fragrances like Cranberry Spice, Cozy Fireside, or
    Christmas Cottage.

  4. Good post. I learn something new and challenging on sites I stumbleupon everyday.
    It will always be interesting to read through articles from other writers and practice something from their sites.

  5. I came across this post from StackOverflow while researching this topic. While doing so, I’ve found a project from Spring called “Spring Loaded” and provided an answer that worked for me at:

    Have you tried that before? How do you think of that as a solution? Do you think it’s a “better” or more “up-to-date” solution?

    Thanks for the great info here!

  6. Thanks, I’ll add it to the list. It is an up-to-date alternative to other hot-replace solutions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.